Yes, a criminal offense can absolutely affect your naturalization application (Form N-400). When applying to become a U.S. citizen, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) requires you to demonstrate Good Moral Character (GMC) for a specific period before filing and up until you take the Oath of Allegiance. Any criminal history can raise serious questions about whether you meet this essential requirement. Let’s dive deeper into how this works and which criminal offenses affect you the most.
What exactly is “Good Moral Character” (GMC)?
Good Moral Character (GMC) is a legal requirement that means you have been a person of good standing, sticking to the moral standards of the average U.S. citizen in your community. During your naturalization process, demonstrating that you are, and have been, a trustworthy and law-abiding individual is essential.
The required period for demonstrating good moral character is generally 5 years immediately preceding your naturalization process (or 3 years if you applied based on marriage to a U.S. citizen). This is called the “statutory period.” Keep in mind that USCIS is not limited to just that time frame. They may take a look at your entire criminal history, even offenses that took place years ago. All this in order to determine your current moral character through the totality of the circumstances.
A qualified immigration attorney is key during your application process. Contact us and we’ll review your case.
Criminal offenses that result in a permanent bar
While some criminal offenses can be overlooked or forgiven by USCIS, there are some crimes that are considered severe and result in an automatic permanent bar to establishing good moral character. This makes you ineligible for naturalization indefinitely.
The most serious convictions that result in a permanent bar include:
- Murder: A conviction for murder at any time.
- Aggravated felonies: A conviction for an aggravated felony on or after November 29, 1990. The term “aggravated felony” in immigration law is very broad and includes many offenses that may only be considered misdemeanors under state law, such as certain theft or fraud crimes if the sentence was one year or longer.
If you have a conviction for a permanent bar offense, you cannot naturalize. It is critical to consult an attorney if you believe your past offense might fall under this category.
Conditional bars during the statutory period
Aside from the offenses mentioned above, most others don’t create a permanent bar. However, they could create a conditional bar. These are activities or offenses committed during the statutory period, and they automatically result in establishing that you do not have good moral character for that period.
Examples of acts that generally result in a conditional bar include:
- Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude (CIMTs): Conviction or admission of one or more CIMTs (like theft, fraud, or certain assault offenses), with some exceptions for a single “petty offense.”
- Controlled substance violations: Violations of any U.S. or foreign law relating to a controlled substance.
- Confinement of 180 days or more: Being confined to a penal institution for an aggregate of 180 days or more as a result of a conviction.
- False testimony: Giving false testimony under oath to obtain an immigration benefit (perjury).
If your offense falls under a conditional bar, you have to wait until the statutory period has passed since the conviction, release from confinement, or end of probation/parole before you can apply again and establish good moral character.
We recommend that you see: Exploring non-immigrant visas: H-1B, F-1, and more
The “Catch-All” clause: other unlawful acts
Beyond the automatic bars, USCIS can deny an application under a “catch-all” clause for unlawful acts that adversely reflect upon your moral character. This gives the officer discretion to look at the totality of your circumstances.
- Driving Under the Influence (DUI/DWI): While a single DUI conviction may not be an automatic conditional bar, multiple DUI convictions during the statutory period are often considered a lack of GMC. USCIS officers review the facts of the case, looking for patterns of behavior or evidence of disregard for the law.
- Failure to Support Dependents: Willful failure or refusal to support dependents (like not paying child support or alimony) can lead to a finding of a lack of GMC unless extenuating circumstances are established.
- Other Minor Offenses: Even reckless or habitual traffic infractions, or a pattern of minor arrests, can be viewed by an officer as showing a lack of respect for the law and the community’s standards.
In these discretionary cases, providing compelling evidence of rehabilitation and reformation (such as completion of counseling, proof of sustained sobriety, or community service) is vital to overcome the negative finding.
Critical advice: you must disclose everything
The most common and devastating mistake applicants make is failing to disclose an offense on Form N-400.
You must disclose every single arrest, citation, conviction, or detention you have ever had, anywhere in the world, regardless of whether:
- The charges were dropped.
- The record was sealed or expunged.
- The event occurred decades ago.
- You only paid a small fine (like a traffic ticket).
Failing to disclose a criminal offense is considered false testimony or perjury and is an independent, permanent bar to establishing Good Moral Character. USCIS runs thorough background checks and will find the information. Your best and only option is to be completely honest and prepared to present all certified court documents.
Navigating the naturalization process with any criminal history is a complex legal matter that requires specialized knowledge. Don’t hesitate to contact us and we’ll review your case. Your story matters to us.
If you found our article useful, please share it with someone who might need it. And don’t forget to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok, as well as check out all our services at jamesimmigrationlaw.com.